Richard Carwardine, Righteous Strife, 1st ed., Signed on Bookplate

With Righteous Strife, Richard Carwardine gives renewed attention to the crucible of contending religious nationalisms, out of which were forged emancipation, Lincoln’s reelection, and his second inaugural address.

How did slavery figure in God’s plan? Was it the providential role of government to abolish this sin and build a righteous nation? Or did such a mission amount to “religious tyranny” and “pulpit politics,” in an effort to strip the southern states of their God-given rights? In 1861, in an already fracturing nation, the tensions surrounding this moral quandary cracked the United States in half, and even formed rifts within the North itself, where antislavery religious nationalists butted heads with conservative religious nationalists over their visions for America’s future.

At the center of this melee stood Abraham Lincoln, who would turn to his own faith for guidance, proclaiming more days of national fasting and thanksgiving than any other president before or since. These pauses for spiritual reflection provided the inspirational rhetoric and ideological fuel that sustained the war.

With Righteous Strife, Richard Carwardine gives renewed attention to the crucible of contending religious nationalisms, out of which were forged emancipation, Lincoln’s reelection, and his second inaugural address. No understanding of the American Civil War is complete without accounting for this complex dance between church and state—one that continues to define our nation.

Carwardine, Richard. RIGHTEOUS STRIFE: HOW WARRING RELIGIOUS NATIONALISTS FORGED LINCOLN’S UNION. NY: Penguin Random House, 2025, 1st ed; 596p., illus., photographs, notes, bibliography, index.